ODA research seminar by Janis Zickfeld
The Aftermath of Exposure: How Informational, Evaluative, and Economic Feedback Shape (Un)Ethical Behavior
Info about event
Time
Location
1834-142
Organizer
The ODA Section invites you to an ODA research seminar presented by Janis Zickfeld:
The Aftermath of Exposure: The Effect of Feedback on (Un)Ethical Behavior
Abstract
Most research on (un)ethical behavior examines interventions applied before a decision, such as deterrence or moral reminders. Much less is known about how feedback received after the behavior shapes future conduct. We propose a framework of three types of ex post feedback, each working through a distinct process: informational (cognitive), evaluative (affective), and economic (cost-benefit). Each takes a different form after ethical (confirmation, praise, reward) versus unethical behavior (confrontation, blame, penalty). Study 1 (N = 314) surveyed everyday experiences. Confrontation occurred mostly in close relationships and elicited anger, guilt, and shame, whereas praise elicited positive feelings and often came from strangers. Study 2 (N = 510) used vignettes varying behavior, situation, observer closeness, and feedback type. Penalties after unethical behavior provoked anger and damaged the relationship with the observer without changing moral judgments or guilt, whereas praise and rewards after ethical behavior increased positive feelings and closeness. Studies 3a and 3b (N = 1,343; N = 2,995) used an incentivized tax evasion game. Economic feedback was most effective in curbing unethical behavior but produced the most negative affect. Informational and evaluative feedback were more effective than no feedback. A further experiment (N = 3,019) replicated these findings for rule-following behavior, identifying repeated feedback as more effective. We integrate the results in a formal utility model of ethical conduct capturing sanction costs, moral costs, intrinsic benefits of honesty and transgression, rule clarification, and economic rewards. The findings inform how institutions and individuals can respond to (un)ethical behavior.
Everyone is welcome!